Selasa, 22 Desember 2009

Indonesian Competition Law


Preface


Record engraved that competition policy and law regime is begun when American antitrust law (Sherman Act) passed in 1890. This act was exist to response the concentration of political and economic power dominated key industries (railroads, oil, steel, sugar and others) in America. Then, the Clayton Act (1914) which covers both specific practices and specific structural issues was also implemented. The voyage is continued with the establishment of Trade Commission Act (1914) that shaped US Federal Trade Commission as an “expert body” to develop and refine national competition law. Those laws have been amended numerous times, but it core elements remain. As for Asia, the competition policy and law regime is marked by the enactment of the first competition law in Asia, the Japan Act Concerning Prohibition of Private Monopolization and Maintenance of Fair Trade (Act No.54 of 14, 1947 which refer as “AMA”). This Act, which was enacted in occupied Japan with the aim of democratizing Japan’s economic system, was strongly influenced by the U.S. Anti-Trust Act.


Indonesian has its owned story on the embarkation of its national competition law and policy. At first, Indonesian economy was traced for having a bad description in the past time, especially in the decades of the 1970s and 1980s, where the government dominated major mining, manufacturing and agricultural activities that create concentrated industries, large state-owned sectors and inefficient firms. Experts estimate that as much as 40% of non-agricultural gross domestic product (GDP) was accounted for government entities. Although to some extents, the economic development is progressing, still, their challenges were remain. This can be seen from the characteristic of business climate. The business opportunities were highlighted by unfair conducts, such as privileges for some people/groups only.


In 1990s, some academician rose issues on the need of competition policy and law in Indonesia. Some economist argued that the law shall guarantee a fair business environment in Indonesia. There was a debate whilst drafting the law. One of the issues was the limitations based on market share threshold, in which the government, private sectors, and most economists agreed that the law shall focus on business conduct rather than market structure. They argued market share’s limitation as a policy without economic rationale and would caused counter-productive toward national investment. Despite of the debate, in 1995 some academicians together with parliament members discussed major points that shall be regulated by the national competition policy and law. However, this draft was not getting enough consideration which mostly because of the politic and economic situations during those days that did not favorable for such kind of law.


In 1997, as many other countries in South Asia, Indonesia has been in the center of a long and strenuous economic crisis, which worsen along with the world’s economic turn down, reaching its lowest point in 1998. Some argued that one of the factors influenced the crisis is that Indonesia did not stipulate a clear competition policy. At this point, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) comes with their bail out package to assist many countries in South East Asia. Indonesia was part of their objective.


The 1997 financial crisis and the insistence of that a number of policy reforms be introduced created a dramatic change in the regulatory environment in Indonesia. Under IMF Letter of Intent for loan-rescue program in January 1998, among fifty points outlined in the letter, there were at least seven proposals for the need of national competition law. Most of their program was extensive and covered reforms in many areas including reduction in some export taxes; elimination of the clove monopoly; liberalization of imports of many agricultural commodities; reduction in import tariffs; removal of trade monopolies in cement, rattan and plywood; removal of local content requirements for automobiles; removal of restrictions on Foreign Domestic Investment and enforcement of extensive macroeconomic targets. Furthermore, the IMF also required Indonesia to pass laws that ensure fair competition. This eventually led to the enactment of the Law No. 5/1999 concerning the Prohibition of Monopolistic Practices and Unfair Business Competition in 5 March 1999. This law was implemented a year after, while business actors where given time for self-adjustment for six month after its enactment.


Substance of the Competition Law


Indonesian competition law (the Law No. 5/1999) armed with some visionary objectives that believe will be as solution for regulate more conducive business environment in Indonesia. This law is aims to safeguard the interests of the public and to improve national economic efficiency as one of the efforts to improve the people’s welfare; to create conducive business climate through the stipulation of fair business competition in order to ensure the certainty of equal business opportunities for large, middle, as well as small-scale business actors in Indonesia; to prevent monopolistic practices and or unfair business competition that may be committed by business actors; and the creation of effectiveness and efficiency in business activities.


This law contains eleven chapters and fifty three articles with three major substantive that coup business behaviors that identified often occurs in business strategic. These major substantives are prohibited agreements, prohibited activities, and abuse of dominant position. Prohibited agreements rules several business activities, namely oligopoly, price fixing, price discrimination, price below market price, resale price maintenance, market division, boycotts, cartels, trusts, oligopsony, vertical integration, exclusive dealing, tie-sales and exclusive dealing, and agreement with foreign business actors. Prohibited activities rules several business activities like monopoly, monopsony, market control, predatory pricing, swindling cost of production, bid rigging, conspiracy in obtaining business secret, and impeding production and marketing of competitor’s product. As for the activities under abuse of dominant position, the Law No. 5/1999 regulates several behaviors, namely abuse of dominant position itself, interlocking directorate, cross-ownership, and merger and acquisition.


The Law No. 5/1999 also provides several exemptions of the law, namely:

1. actions and or agreements intended to implement applicable laws and regulations; or

2. agreements related to intellectual property rights, such as licenses, patents, trademarks, copyright, industrial product design, integrated electronic circuits, and trade secrets as well as agreements related to franchise; or

3. agreements for the stipulation of technical standards of goods and or services which do not inhibit, and or impede competition; or

4. agency agreements which do not stipulate the re-supply of goods and or services at a price level lower than the contracted price; or

5. cooperation agreements in the field of research for the upgrading or improvement of the living standard of society at large; or

6. international agreements ratified by the Government of the Republic of Indonesia; or

7. export-oriented agreements and or actions not disrupting domestic needs and or supplies; or

8. business actors of the small-scale group; or

9. activities of cooperatives aimed specifically at serving their members.


The law also exempted monopoly and or concentration of activities related to the production and or marketing of goods and or services affecting the livelihood of society at large and branches of production of a strategic nature for the state. This exemption can be applied if this monopoly is implemented by State-Owned Enterprises and or institutions formed or appointed by the Government that stipulated in a certain Law.


Speaking of applied approaches in Indonesian competition law, it can be concluded that the Law No. 5/1999 focus on rule of reason approach, in term that they shall proved any violation had caused the existence of monopolistic practices or unfair business competition. This shown by end of several provisions that stipulate “…that may result in monopolistic practices and unfair business competition”. The per se illegal rule also been used in a limited term for few behaviors, such as price fixing cartel, cross-ownership, and such. Moreover, under this law, monopolistic practices is define by Article 1 as the centralization of economic power by one or more business actors, resulting in the control of the production and or marketing of certain goods and or services thus resulting in unfair business competition and potentially harmful to the interests of the public. While unfair business competition is defined as competition among business actors in conducting activities for the production and or marketing of goods and or services in an unfair or unlawful or anti-competition manner.


Notwithstanding with these approaches, Indonesian competition law also defines market share threshold as the common practice in defining the existence of dominant position, market structure (monopoly and oligopoly), and other behaviors. The Law no. 5/1999 apply market share threshold of 50% as an indication of an indication of monopolist or a business actor with a dominant position and 75% for an oligopolist or two or three business actors with dominant position. Furthermore, the Law also stipulates violation in a cross-ownership where one business actor owns a majority of shares in controlling 50% of a market, or a group of firms owns a majority shares in companies controlling 75% of a market.


The Competition Authority


Article 30 of the Law No. 5/1999 gives mandate to the Commission for the Supervision of Business Competition, Republic of Indonesia (hereafter refer as “KPPU”) to the supervision of the implementation of the Law. This commission is an independent institution free from the Government’s and other parties’ influence and authority, with their responsibility to the President.


KPPU is consisting of thirteen Commissioners which lead by a Chairman and a Vice Chairman that being appointed among them annually. The Commissioners themselves are appointed for a term of office of 5 (five) years and could be dismissed at any time by the President upon the approval of the People’s Legislative Assembly. This independent commission has the jurisdictions to evaluate agreements, business activities and or actions of business actors, and the existence or nonexistence of misuse of dominant position that may result in monopolistic practices and or unfair business competition. KPPU also has authorities to provide advice and recommendation concerning Government policies related to monopolistic practices and or unfair business competition, prepare guidelines and or publications related to the Law, and submit periodic reports on the results of the KPPU’s work to the President and the People’s Legislative Assembly (DPR).


Furthermore, for the uninterrupted implementation of its duties, the Commission shall be assisted by a Secretariat which led by an Executive Director. The Secretariat itself consists of four directorates as part of their main functions to supervise the implementation of competition law. These directorates are Directorate of Law Enforcement, Directorate of Competition Policy, Directorate of Communication, and Directorate of Administration. They also established five regional offices that scatter in five major cities in Indonesia. Number of human resources of this institution is varied up to 272 staffs, with only 30% of which are entitled a jurisdiction to handle competition cases.


Case Handling Procedure


Case handling procedure in Indonesian competition law system is based on the KPPU’s regulation No. 1/2006 regarding the Procedures of Case Handling in KPPU. While procedure for objection process is regulated by the Supreme Court Regulation No. 1/2003, which had been amend with the Supreme Court Regulation No. 3/2005. Mainly, every case in Indonesia’s competition agency is come from report and at their own initiative. This initiative could be come from business actor monitoring activity that defines as a series of activities conducted by Commission Secretariat to identify the completeness and clarity with regard to the violation alleged or reasonably alleged to have been committed by the Business Actor based on the data and information developing in the public. This initiative also could comes from they own research and or inputs from the Commissioner.


Each report or result of initiative will be shaped by prosecution division that will be studying provision that would be implied to the impeachment. The result will be submitted to the highest decision maker in the competition agency, namely a Commission Assembly that consists of its Chairman, Vice Chairman, and the Commissioners. If it is decided to hold an examination, then this case will be advance to a preliminary examination (for 30 days) that will summon reporting party and reported parties to get information needed to prove the violation. In this context, the examination will be conducted by a Commission Council (which consist of three Commissioners) assisted by several investigators and registrars.


Moreover, should this preliminary examination found sufficient evidence to convince the reported parties and the affirmed it, then they could be rewarded by an order to change it behavior. If not, the competition agency could proceed the investigation to a follow-up examination for 60 days. Preceding the series of examination, Commission Council will hold meetings to formulate its final decision within 30 days. During this process, reported parties are given opportunity to deliver his/her opinion or defense related to the alleged violation accused to him/her.


To ensure control on the competition agency’s decision, each business actor is provided opportunity to file an objection to the District Court. In this regards, the competition agency would act as a Party. It is also interested to note that in a competition case objection in Indonesia, the District Court can not be allowed to summon additional witnesses in their examination. The only way to do this is by requesting the competition agency to conduct an additional examination on the witnesses and report it to the District Court. The entire process for objection in the District Court will consume 30 days at maximum until the decision. The decision by the District Court also can be objected to the Supreme Court as the highest judiciary in Indonesia.


Performances and Recent News


Ever since eight years of establishment, Indonesian competition agency has shaped significant result in creating fair business environment in Indonesia. This showed by number of decision and policy advice and recommendation to the Government. Based on their Annual Report for 2007, competition law enforcement has revealed that they received 761 reports from public, which vary between competition issues (74%) and others (26%). Most of cases handled by Indonesian competition agency are related to bid rigging which consumed 35% of total cases, respectively related to allegation of refusal and or entry of barrier for certain business actors to carry out business activity in the same relevant market. As a result, Indonesia has handled 94 competition cases, in which 56 of them had been decided, 21 cases are terminated in preliminary investigation process due to no sufficient proof or change in behavior conduct, while 14 other cases are still in process investigation. As stipulated earlier, the competition agency’s decision can be appeal to the District Court and the Supreme Court. Until today, they recorded eight decisions that been affirmed by the Supreme Court. Three of which were already compensated their fine to the Government.


In competition advocacy process this agency had recorded marvelous result by delivering 41 policy advices that primarily related to policy giving effects to business competition climate in Indonesia. It proved that policy harmonization has been conducted effectively through positive response from the government or regulatory bodies. In order to create and preserve secure relationship amongst government, Indonesian competition agency has been developing program for harmonization of competition policy. This program is enacted through; giving policy advice and recommendation to the Government in every policies that potentially distort the competition, bilateral meeting, dissemination, and joint socialization. Moreover, Government is also frequently asked for bilateral meeting to get competition agency’s opinion on several cases which related to competition issues. In line with the establishment of our five regional representatives, this program is beginning to tap on some Local Government policies. Harmonization programs are also touch upon creating mutual relation with the Supreme Court through joint activities and continual bilateral meeting. Establishment of Supreme Court regulation on appeal procedure for competition cases is one of the results for this fine harmonization.


Challenges


Efforts by Indonesian competition agency were not truly smooth as they also experience lot of strain and in-acceptance from business actor, the judiciary, nor the government itself. For those, they always made various efforts and recorded great success in improving the enforcement of fair competition policies and law in Indonesia. Public awareness toward competition policy has been improved through the capacity development and institutional building. However, the success is not without another parties’ role, as they received various supports. There are 3 (three) lessons learned by the competition agency after 8 years of their existence.


Firstly, various approach namely through “joint activities” in order to introduce and to promote competition law to the Supreme Court or another legal institutions, is a must. Good relationship with judges in Supreme Court may help the competition agency in introducing competition law to the District Court. They also keeps its active approach to convince Supreme Court on the importance of legal framework to enforce competition law, especially on the procedure of objection submission, has encouraged Supreme Court to enact Regulations No. 3/2005 concerning The Procedures of Submission for Objections towards KPPU’s Decisions.


Secondly, Indonesian competition agency’s efforts are not restricted only to shift the anti-competition behavior in the market but have departed beyond advocacy role to improve government regulations that impede competitions and create market distortion. Through intensive advocacy and by continuously maintaining its relationship with the Government, the agency has opened the access for consultation between the competition agency and Government in various issues, especially on essential facilities.


Thirdly, they viewed that participation in international forum is also important. Currently Indonesian competition agency is developing cooperation and sustainable aid with international organizations such as APEC, OECD, ICN, WorldBank, ADB, AANZ, and UNCTAD. They also are maintaining fruitful bilateral relationship with international competition agencies, namely Japan, Germany, South Korea, Taiwan, USA, and Australia. They believed these active contributions will help them in its capacity building that in line with its program to develop its human resources.


Indonesian competition agency realized that competition law is not an individual stand out policy. It requires the role of every element of government for its implementation, both in executive and judicative level. To create harmony amongst the institutions is not an easy task for them. After its eight years performing its role in law enforcement and as a supervisory agency for competition law, this institution still faces many challenges. The challenges are related into two main areas. One is about human resources development and the other is about institutional development. Human resources development related to the internal management such as remuneration system, guidelines and standard of operational procedures. On the other hand, institutional development is effected by external factors; among others are their independency on budget and the capacity to internalize competition culture or values into Indonesian economy.

Senin, 10 Agustus 2009

PM: Energy prices must be fairer; Problem rooted in PTT monopoly

Writer: NAREERAT WIRIYAPONG
Published: 25/07/2009 at 12:00 AM
Newspaper section: Business

Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva has vowed to clamp down on energy companies that may be wielding monopoly power at the expense of consumers. He said that hefty profits at PTT Plc reflected in part its monopolistic position in the gas market.

PTT Plc, the largest listed company on the Stock Exchange of Thailand, is 51% owned by the Finance Ministry, and posted 2008 profits of 51 billion baht, prompting complaints among consumer groups of profiteering.

''The government is looking at price structures and trying to make sure the market mechanism works properly to define appropriate marketing margins of retail oil prices,'' the premier said at a dinner talk held by the University of Wisconsin Alumni in Thailand.

''Actually, PTT's profit is largely due to its monopolistic position in the gas business. This is caused by the improper structure of PTT, set before it was privatised,'' he said.

According to PTT, the gas business had earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA) of 54 billion baht in 2008, out of the total 156 billion baht of EBITDA the group earned.

Mr Abhisit said he aimed to have a proper price structure in place for the gas business in the long term even though he admitted it would not be easy.

''I put this issue on my to-do list as part of the government's attempt to promote good governance in the corporate sector,'' he added.

Vitaya Wangchitaruck, executive vice-president of retail marketing at PTT, said that after the recent fuel price increase of 80 satang on Thursday, PTT's margin rose to 1.30 baht a litre from 50 satang.

Of the total margin, PTT gets only 80 satang, which is just enough for the company to manage with expenses of 60-70 satang per litre, he said.

Through its one-third market share in the retail oil business, Mr Vitaya said PTT played a role in delaying the price increase, annoying foreign rivals such as Shell, Esso and Caltex.

''Thailand has some of the world's best petrol stations but the margin on petrol is among the lowest globally. Even in neighbouring Laos, Cambodia and Burma, margins are higher than in Thailand,'' Mr Vitaya said.

''At PTT, we have done our best on retail oil prices because we know this affects consumers substantially and impacts the government's performance as well.''

Despite the premier's statements, PTT shares on the Stock Exchange of Thailand rose yesterday by one baht to 233 baht, in trade worth 1.62 billion.

Mr Abhisit, meanwhile, admitted that the government could not do much to encourage banks to extend loans to businesses, especially those in hard-hit sectors such as tourism.

''Tight credit is a serious issue. It is a global phenomenon and actually reflects the nature of the banking business when the economy slumps, because they are more cautious,'' he said.

''The government has instructed banks that they should look at the potential of the business. The fundamentals of many tourism businesses, for example, are good but many operators are in trouble because of the political unrest.''

The premier also brushed aside criticism that his government had not offered assistance to revive exports even though the sector accounts for as much as 70% of Thailand's gross domestic product.

''It is not true that the government is not paying attention to this problem. But the drops in exports are mainly caused because our trading partners have less purchasing power or are not in a mood to consume because of the economic problems they are facing,'' he said.

The Bank of Thailand, meanwhile, has managed the baht cautiously to make sure the Thai currency is moving in line with others in the region.

''We already learned in the past that intervention to make the baht appreciate or weaken caused severe damage,'' Mr Abhisit said.


http://www.bangkokpost.com/business/economics/20915/pm-energy-prices-must-be-fairer

KPPU claims new authority over intellectual property rights abuse

The Jakarta Post | Thu, 05/07/2009 9:22 PM | Business

The Business Competition Supervisory Commission (KPPU) has launched new guidelines for the implementation of the 1999 law on monopoly that would enable the anti-monopoly watchdog to probe violations of intellectual property rights.

Prior to the new guidelines, the KPPU is prohibited under Article 50 point B of the anti-trust law to handle cases related to any form of intellectual property rights abuse.

“Intellectual property rights have always been exclusive (to the owner). With the issuance of this guideline, that is no longer the case,” KPPU director of communication A. Junaidi told a discussion in Jakarta on Thursday.

The new guidelines essentially say the KPPU is allowed to probe such cases if the intellectual property rights ownership automatically creates an abuse of dominant power in the market.

An abuse of dominant power, the guidelines say, occurs when: a business competition is no longer efficient in terms of ability to generate benefit for customers, rights owner bundle its main product with other types of product in a sales package, issuer holds monopoly of raw material distribution – unless it is meant as a way to maintain quality and secrecy of product, and issuer limit any type of product advancement by licensee.

Junaidi said consumers would benefit from the implementation of the new arrangement as product sellers could no longer force consumers to buy bundled products.

http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2009/05/07/kppu-claims-new-authority-over-intellectual-property-rights-abuse.html

KPPU, Carrefour trade dispute heating up

The Jakarta Post , JAKARTA | Fri, 05/15/2009 12:31 PM | Business


The anti-monopoly watchdog has upped the stakes in its competition investigation of PT Carrefour Indonesia, and is now pursuing an examination of alleged monopolistic practices on the part of the retail giant.


The decision to upgrade the investigation level was taken after the Business Competition Supervisory Commission (KPPU) found “strong indications” of unfair business practices carried out by Carrefour during its 30-day preliminary investigation, said communication director Ahmad Djunadi Thursday.

The KPPU now has up to 90 working days to hand down a judgement to Carrefour, which is being accused of monopolistic practices in the country’s retail sector following its acquisition of supermarket operator PT Alfa Retailindo.


KPPU is accusing Carrefour of misusing its strengthened bargaining position to charge additional costs such as promotional fees, and listing fees to Carrefour’s suppliers.

Such practices are in violation of the 1999 anti-monopoly law.


The bargaining power of Carrefour, KPPU claimed, had improved significantly since the 2008 acquisition of Alfa both with suppliers (market share from 45 to 67 percent) and consumers (market share from 38 to 48.4 percent).


Carrefour responded by insisting the allegations were untrue.

“Carrefour’s stance is still the same. Our company does not monopolize the market and does not break any trade laws,” responded Irawan Kadarman, Carrefour’s corporate communications director.

Irawan said that his company has not received any letter from KPPU regarding the lengthy investigation.


“Therefore, I cannot give you detailed information of what our company is going to do,” Irawan said.

However, he added that Carrefour would cooperate and be willing to continue its communications with KPPU in order to find satisfactory solutions for both sides.


He reiterated the company’s position that based on AC Nielsen’s recent research, after the acquisition, Carrefour’s market share was only 17 percent. It remains unclear what the consequences may be for Carrefour if KPPU finds the company to be in breach of competition rules.


Allegations against Carrefour on unfair business practices have not only been made in Indonesia.

In 2006, Carrefour was fined US$1.5 million by the Korean Fair Trade Commision (KFTC) because the retailer was found to have forced suppliers to sell goods at heavy discounts for certain periods, according to KPPU chairman Benny Pasaribu, after a meeting with KFTC’s top executives Thursday.

In a meeting with Yong-Ho Baek, chairman of the Korea’s anti-monopoly watchdog, Benny said KPPU and KFTC had discussed the Carrefour case here due to similarities with the case in Korea.


In 2006, KFTC also faced another major case on an acquisition involving Carrefour. In this case it was Eland Retail, a local Korean retailer, which acquired Carrefour in Korea.


However, Eland took the KFTC objection to court and eventually won its case.

Asked about the possibility of the same outcome happening in the Carrefour-Alfa case, with the KPPU possibly losing the case in court, Benny answered: “Of course the same outcome may happen again.

“That is why KPPU and KFTC have discussed the case. Both watchdogs try to learn from each other’s experiences.” (mrs)


http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2009/05/15/kppu-carrefour-trade-dispute-heating.html

Temasek seeks a review on monopoly case

The Jakarta Post , Jakarta | Tue, 05/26/2009 12:35 PM | Business


Temasek holdings Pte, the Singapore-based investment giant, has restarted its legal battle over allegations it had breached the country's antimonopoly laws by registering a case review with the Supreme Court while insisting its innocence.


Late last year, the Supreme Court in principle upheld a decision by a lower court which ruled that Temasek was guilty of violating the antimonopoly law through its cross-ownership in the country's two largest cell phone firms - PT Telkomsel and PT Indosat, as alleged by the Business Competition Supervisory Agency (KPPU).


The cross ownership, according to the KPPU, could have led to prices fixing.

Among the punishments that Temasek must bear is a fine of Rp 15 billion (about US$1.46 million), in addition that the company has had to relinquish ownership of one of the two companies.


The decision is actually no longer relevant as Temasek subsidiary Singapore Technologies Telemedia (STT) Pte has already sold its entire stake in Indosat to Qatar Telecom (QTel) in a deal worth $1.8 billion.

Temasek now only indirectly owns Telkomsel, through Singapore Telecommunications Ltd (SingTel), another of its subsidiaries. It controls a 54 percent stake in SingTel, which in turn owns 35 percent of Telkomsel.


Still, despite no longer owning a stake in Indosat, thus clearing them of the cross-ownership allegation, Temasek would continue to defend its position and continue to seek justice to clear its name of any alleged antimonopoly infringement, according to Todung Mulya Lubis, Temasek's lawyer,.

"Temasek believes that the court can once more thoroughly examine our evidence and prove the company's innocence," Todung said Monday.


He however refused to elaborate on what new evidence the company has to back up its case.

Findings of new evidence are a prerequisite before registering a Supreme Court case review.

Temasek believes the previous courts had misinterpreted the anti monopoly law.

"Temasek has never given instructions to subsidiaries regarding the managements of Telkomsel and Indosat. So it cannot be considered as monopolistic (in fixing prices)," said Todung. (mrs)


http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2009/05/26/temasek-seeks-a-review-monopoly-case.html